Yes, Virginia, there is a hill worth dying on… but ‘A Christmas Carol’ isn’t it!

So I’ve always been to the point. I hate stupid administrators who hear one buzz word completely freak out. Buzzwords like ‘Christmas’.

I’ve had my fair share of dealing with parents who disagree about certain novels. I’ve heard  The Hunger Games = violence, “Harry Potter” = witchcraft, and of course the infamous “The Catcher in the Rye”.

…but “A Christmas Carol”?

I was catching up with a teacher over the weekend who informed her that their Supervisor (whom now I will refer to as “Stupid-visor”) did not want a lesson on “A Christmas Carol” on the day before break because it has nothing to do with complex reading, ELA Common Core Standards, and is religious.

Um…WHAT?!?

I worked with someone who was a legend at speaking in idiom to the point that we pretty much spoke to each other like that all day. One of his many famous phrases was “There are hills worth dying on; this is not one of them.” I could not agree more in this case.

“A Christmas Carol” is literary staple around the world.  Countless themes, superb characters, and a simple plot allows millions to understand.  I think you could adapt it to any holiday for that matter.  The message wouldn’t change.  Anyway, do a simple search of “A Christmas Carol common core lessons and ideas” and you will come up with THOUSANDS of ideas and designs.  Students can easily engage in the story and can prepare to discuss and write in-depth responses about an excerpt. I came across one website that had  Grade 7 ELA Common Core Standards for reading literature, writing, and speaking and listening:

• READING: LITERATURE – RL.7.1-4, 6-7, 10
• WRITING – W.7.1-10
• SPEAKING AND LISTENING – SL.7.1-6

The stupid-visor then tried to pose the argument that it is a public school and this is a religious biblical propaganda.  I was dumbfounded.  It always amazes me to see who sits in these leadership positions… and we really wonder sometimes?

I told that teacher to call the Stupid-visor out — and that this is non-sense.  The teacher did, and the Stupid-Visor dug shoes deeper into the sand.

Stuff like that gets out really quick.  Anyone looking to move up or around a new position and people catch wind of this?!  Congratulations, you’re iced out.

There are indeed educational hills worth dying on – saying that ‘A Christmas Carol’ is not appropriate for middle school students because it is not aligned with CommonCore and is uber-religious is not one of them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s